Connect with us
A Matter of Life and Death
#AMatterofLifeandDeath
CastDavid Niven, Roger Livesey, Raymond Massey, Kim Hunter, Marius Goring
Year released1945
Spoiler alert
Blog entry
Examining Peter, what other questions would you ask him, to differentiate between fantasy and psychopathology?
By radio, Squadron Leader Peter David Carter tells radio operator June, "... I’d rather have written that than flown through Hitler’s legs." (0:06)
Peter asks Conductor 71, "Are you cracked?"
”This is absolutely fantastic...”
Conductor 71, referring to June: ”... She is charming.” (0:27)
Peter: "June, do I look cracked?" (0:32)
Dr. Frank Reeves tells June, "... You’d be surprised how many diagnoses I’ve formed up here."
Reeves: ”... I had a talk to his group medical officer too...”
”And he has hallucinations?”
”But he definitely sees things?”
June: ”And hears.” (0:35)
Woman: "Be kind and courteous to this gentleman."
Man: ”... Your name, honest gentleman?” (0:40)
Reeves asks Peter, "You’ve never had any visions or hallucinations before?"
”What was the cause of your father’s death?”
”Did you ever have a rather nasty bang on the head?”
Peter tells June, referring to the girls, ”... confidentially, they’re rather knock-kneed.”
Reeves asks Peter, ”Have you had a similar hallucination before?”
”... do you believe in the survival of human personality after death?”
”... have you imagined recently that you’ve smelt something that couldn’t possibly be there?” (0:41)
Reeves answers June, referring to Peter, "I gave him a tablet."
”... I know the patient.”
”... medically...”
June: ”Will he have any more hallucinations?”
”Seeing things... talking to a nonexistent man...”
”He’s not going mad then?...”
Reeves: ”He’s having a series of highly organized hallucinations... sense of smell or taste...”
”... we’ll invent the greatest lie in medical history... don’t worry about him... ” (0:47)
Conductor 71 answers Peter, "A shock." (0:53)
Surgeon Dr. McEwan asks Reeves, "... Are you sure of your diagnosis?"
Reeves: ”... He had slight concussion... these highly organized hallucinations...”
McEwan: ”... There’s no crisis...”
Reeves: ”... there is a crisis...”
McEwan: ”Insanity?”
Reeves: ”... He only sleeps when I drug him... Stupidity has saved many a man from going mad.”
”Hallucinations, of course...”
”... Nothing he invents is entirely fantastic...” (0:57)
Reeves tells Conductor 71, "... It’s like escaping from bondage to a raving madman."
”... Plato would probably talk about perceptions and causations.” (1:00)
Reeves injects Peter. (1:03)
The medic tells June, referring to Reeves, "... it was a fine piece of diagnosis." (1:07)
One nurse asks another, "An atropine injection, sister?" (1:09)
Reeves: “... I subpoena flying officer Trubshawe as a witness." (1:12)
Reeves, tells Peter, referring to Trubshawe: "I subpoenaed him..."
”Well, doesn’t it worry you I’m no lawyer?” (1:13)
Judge, referring to Peter: "... He claims negligence and superior rights and responsibilities arising out of that negligence..." (1:18)
Label on anesthesia equipment: "ETHER" (1:26)
Prosecutor Abraham Farlan: "But Peter Carter’s character, sir..." (1:27)
Reeves: "My diagnosis was right..."
Farlan: ”Dr. Reeves, we are not here to check your diagnosis...”
Farlan asks Peter, ”... Did you consciously try to influence the emotions of this young American lady?”
”... I’ll have you committed.”
Peter: ”Commit away...”
Peter asks Reeves, ”Have you gone mad?”
Peter: ”You are mad.” (1:36)