Connect with us
The Son
#TheSonMovie
CastHugh Jackman, Laura Dern, Vanessa Kirby, Zen McGrath, Hugh Quarshie, Anthony Hopkins
Year released2022
Spoiler alert
Blog entry
Although Nicholas certainly displays depressed mood at times, the explanation for his disturbance appears to lie in the dysfunction in his family system, going back to his paternal grandfather, rather than in a purely biological process. The unfortunate outcome seems to result from failures in his treatment, such as the failure of his outpatient “therapist” to involve his parents in his treatment, and later, the minimal involvement of his family in this treatment at the psychiatric unit. Had he suffered from, say, Major Depressive Disorder, he likely would have benefited from medication, which apparently was only given to him in the hospital. All the involved adults missed the opportunity to modify the family system.
Both his family and the treating professionals failed to assure a reasonably safe environment for Nicholas at home. Peter made no effort to prevent Nicholas’ access to a loaded hunting rifle after his suicide attempt.
Regardless of whether Nicholas remained in hospital, how would you involve the rest of the family in his treatment? In reality, would the inpatient psychiatrist have discharged Nicholas so readily? The film portrays no coordination of care between the outpatient psychotherapist and the inpatient team and no other plan for follow-up care. Would early family psychotherapy have changed the outcome?
Nicholas Miller tells his business executive father Peter, "If you send me to boarding school, I’ll go crazy..."
”Sometimes I just feel that I’m going crazy, Dad.” (0:10)
Peter tells his wife Beth, referring to Nicholas, "... When I went to see him just now... he had... marks.”
”Scars, on his arm..."
Beth: ”... Don’t worry...” (0:11)
His mother Kate tells NIcholas, "... don’t worry." (0:13)
By telephone, Peter tells Dr. Collins, "... I think he needs to see a therapist..." (0:16)
A senator’s aide tells Peter, referring to the senator, "... He’s in a good mood today." (0:19)
Nicholas tells Beth, referring to his parents’ divorce, "... It was like I was being chopped in half." (0:24)
Nicholas in session with his "therapist." (0:27)
Peter tells Kate, referring to Nicholas, "... He’s behaving himself..." (0:30)
Peter tells Beth, "Worries me he’s on his own all the time." (0:37)
Beth tells Peter, "... talk to him about it... maybe to his therapist..."
”Don’t worry...” (0:44)
Peter tells Nicholas, "... I don’t want you to hurt yourself..."
Nicholas: ”I don’t hurt myself.”
Peter: ”... That’s what I call hurting yourself.”
Nicholas: ”It relieves me.”
Peter: ”... I hope you talk to your therapist...”
”... when you hurt yourself, it’s as if you’re doing it to me.”
Nicholas: ”And when you hurt Mom, you were doing it to me.” (0:46?)
Nicholas bangs his head against the wall. (0:52)
His father Anthony tells Peter, "... bunch of sniveling cowards..."
Peter, referring to his mother: ”... the week before she died...” (0:55)
Beth tells Peter, referring to Nicholas, "... He’s been depressed. He’s still unstable... I’m sorry if this shocks you..."
”... When are you gonna face up to the fact that he’s not right in the head?” (1:03)
Kate tells Nicholas, referring to Peter, "... He worries about you."
”You used to dream about being a writer...”
”... It’s a dream he’s had for a lot of years...” (1:05)
Nicholas tells Peter, referring to Beth, "She wants to turn us against one another."
Nicholas: ”... Are you on drugs?... tried to give you strength and confidence...” (1:10)
Kate tells the ward clerk, "I need the... psychiatric ward." (1:16)
Dr. Liener tells Nicholas and Kate, "Don’t worry..."
”... treat him... there'll be regular visits with the inpatient psychiatrist and Nicholas... ”
”... a social worker will be in to help you with the paperwork... Please don’t worry...” (1:17)
By telephone, Kate tells Peter, ”... Nicholas is having some trouble accepting treatment...” (1:22)
Beth tells Peter, "... Don’t worry."
Peter: ”... I keep catching myself saying... exactly the things my father used to say to me...”
Beth: “... you’re not here. You’re at work all of the time...” (1:24)
Peter tells Nicholas, "Hey, don’t worry."
Nicholas tells Peter and Kate, ”... He stuffs me full of medication...”
Psychiatrist Dr. Harris: ”Nicholas is suffering from acute depression...”
Nicholas: ”... this moron doesn’t understand anything...”
Harris: ”... Suicidal impulses, they’re really difficult to identify, even for the patient... Nicholas is still suffering from a certain disconnect from reality, which is causing him all kind of anxieties, which we can treat...”
”... you need the whole medical team... therapists...”
”... Nicholas needs treatment... That’s a job for a psychiatrist...”
Nicholas: ”... It was a cry for help...”
Harris: ”... Nicholas needs to understand that you support the medical team.”
Harris tells Nicholas, ”... It’ll help you accept your treatment.” (1:30)
Sign: "DEPARTMENT OF PSYCHIATRY" (1:37)
Kate tells Nicholas, "I better get the prescription for you..." (1:42)
Gunshot off camera. Peter and Kate find Nicholas. (1:45)
Nicholas tells Peter, referring to Nicholas’s girlfriend Lena, "... I’m crazy about her..."
Peter: ”I’m so proud of you... so proud of you.”
”... so proud of you.”
Bereavement hallucination? (1:49)
Peter tells Beth, referring to Nicholas, "... he was so intelligent..."
Peter mourns. (1:54)